The median family medicine practice has a clean claim rate of 85.0%, according to MGMA DataDive's 2024 Practice Operations survey of 2023 data. The most quoted target is 95.0%, which puts the typical practice 10.0 points below the goal.

Forvis Mazars showed the median at the Kansas MGMA annual conference in April 2026. The deck does not state the sample size. All medians below are for family medicine practices.

The median and the target

At an 85.0% clean claim rate, 15.0% of claims leave the practice with an error that a payer or clearinghouse can catch. Taylor Johnson, manager of physician practice sustainability at the AMA, gave the target in an AMA article dated August 29, 2025. She said first-pass resolution rates and coding accuracy should reach 95.0%, and days in accounts receivable should stay under 30.

The same MGMA data show where practices stand on that second target. The median family medicine practice carried 69.8 net days in A/R in the 2025 Financials and Operations survey of 2024 data. That is 39.8 days above the AMA's goal. Of the A/R balance, 27.9% was older than 90 days and 22.9% was older than 120 days.

Definitions differ by source. A clearinghouse usually reports the share of claims that pass its edits. Other sources use the share of claims paid on the first pass. Check which one your reports show before you compare against 85.0% or 95.0%.

Clean claim rate and denial rate can disagree

A high clean claim rate does not guarantee payment. Medical Economics published a piece on December 1, 2025 with Bronson Cox, chief operating officer at Encoda. Cox said the clean claim rate shows that a claim passed initial edits and was accepted by the payer, and that it says nothing about whether the claim was paid. His example was a practice with a 95.0% clean claim rate and a 40.0% denial rate. He also described practices that resubmit the same claim 5, 10 or even 15 times.

Cox suggests tracking the first-pass payment rate instead. He said a 1.0% improvement in that rate can have a large financial effect.

The MGMA medians show the same gap in milder form. The median practice had 7.1% of claims denied on first submission in the 2024 data, while 15.0% of claims were not clean in the 2023 data. The two figures come from different survey years, so they cannot be subtracted. Both say that a share of claims needs rework.

Experian Health's 2026 State of Claims survey of 204 staff found that 40.0% said 10.0% or more of their claims are denied. The 2025 figure was 41.0%. Medical Economics reported the results on October 30, 2026. The survey does not split results by organization type.

MeasureMedian, family medicineData year
Clean claim rate85.0%2023
Insurance verification rate87.0%2023
Claims denied on first submission7.1%2024
Net collection percentage97.1%2024
Gross collection percentage49.1%2024
Net days in A/R69.8 days2024
Charge posting lag5.0 days2024

Source: MGMA DataDive 2024 Practice Operations survey (2023 data) and 2025 Financials and Operations survey (2024 data), as shown by Forvis Mazars, April 2026.

Where unclean claims start

A Change Healthcare study from 2024, shown in the same Forvis Mazars deck, splits denial reasons by the stage where the error began. Front-end causes made up 41.0% of denials. Back-end causes made up 34.0%, mid-cycle causes 17.0% and other causes 8.0%.

Within those groups, registration and eligibility errors were the largest single reason at 22.0%. Missing or invalid claim data followed at 16.0%, and medical documentation requests at 14.0%. Authorization and pre-certification caused 13.0%, and services not covered caused 11.0%.

Most of these errors can be caught before the claim is built. The median insurance verification rate was 87.0% in the MGMA 2023 data, so front-end checks start from a base that already leaves room.

The Experian survey points the same way. Services not covered led the 2026 list, named in the top three by 53.0% of respondents. Code inaccuracy was named by 25.0%, and difficulty getting prior authorization by 25.0%.

What rework costs

The Forvis Mazars deck cites Healthcare Business Insight's CY2024 hospital benchmarks for an average cost of $118 to formally appeal one denied claim. The figure comes from hospitals, so a small practice may spend less per appeal. At $118 each, 100 appeals cost $11,800.

The deck also lists rework costs of 10.0% to 25.0% of payments in some cases, covering staff and vendor labor. The Change Healthcare study found that 60.0% of denied claims are never resubmitted. It also reported an 89.0% rise in the national average denial rate between 2016 and the first quarter of 2023.

Unworked denials pull down the net collection rate. The median practice still reached 97.1% net collection, against a gross collection percentage of 49.1%.

How to measure your own rate

Pull two reports each month. The first is the clearinghouse clean claim rate. The second is the share of claims paid on the first remittance. Compare the first to 85.0%, the MGMA median, and the gap between the two reports shows how many accepted claims later fail.

Cox recommends tracking each submission and each payer response across the full life of the claim, so that the cause of a denial can be fixed once. Compare your first-submission denial rate to the 7.1% median, and your A/R days to 69.8.

For reference, the MGMA median charge posting lag for family medicine is 5.0 days.

Sources

Talk to us

Fifteen minutes about your practice and the systems you run.

Book a demo