Medicare Part B overpaid by an estimated $9,322,228,153 in fiscal year 2025, an overpayment rate of 8.2%, according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). The highest rate among the 20 largest codes was 65.2%, for chronic care management (99490).
CMS publishes the code-level detail in the supplemental tables of its CERT claims-review program. Table L1 ranks Part B services by projected overpaid dollars, so the list shows where the money went wrong and how often.
What does the FY2025 Part B error rate cover?
The FY2025 review covered Part B claims submitted from July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024. CMS sampled 11,920 Part B claims and reviewed 11,600 of them. Those claims held 24,983 service lines, and the reviewers paid out $19,047,116 in sample dollars.
Part B paid $114.1 billion in total that year. CMS projected $9.6 billion of it as improper, an improper payment rate of 8.4% with a 95% confidence interval of 7.6% to 9.3%. The overpayment rate in Table L1 is a little lower, 8.2%, because underpayments sit in the 8.4% figure but not in the overpayment figure.
CERT reviews a sample, so each rate carries a margin. A code with 68 reviewed claims has a much wider margin than a code with 450. The table below shows the interval next to every rate for that reason.
For comparison, CMS put the improper payment rate at 5.4% for Part A and 24.1% for durable medical equipment. Across all claim types the rate was 6.6% on $439.9 billion in payments, from 49,061 sampled claims.
Which Part B codes lost the most dollars?
The two largest dollar losses were hospital and office visits. CMS projected $490,503,977 in overpayments for subsequent hospital care at the high level (99233), and $459,838,842 for the established office visit at 30 minutes (99214). Together they account for $950,342,819 of projected overpayments.
The other large codes were therapy and care management services. The table lists the top ten from CMS Table L1, sorted by projected overpaid dollars.
| Code | Claims reviewed | Projected overpaid dollars | Overpayment rate | 95% interval |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 99233 subsequent hospital care, high | 334 | $490,503,977 | 22.1% | 18.2% to 26.1% |
| 99214 office visit, established, 30 min | 450 | $459,838,842 | 5.0% | 3.3% to 6.6% |
| 97110 therapeutic exercises | 214 | $286,653,227 | 25.2% | 17.9% to 32.5% |
| 99215 office visit, established, 40 min | 226 | $245,231,199 | 14.8% | 11.6% to 18.1% |
| 99490 chronic care management, first 20 min | 68 | $205,392,699 | 65.2% | 53.4% to 77.0% |
| 99223 initial hospital care, high | 282 | $182,122,220 | 13.1% | 9.9% to 16.4% |
| 97530 therapeutic activities | 245 | $179,101,995 | 18.1% | 12.5% to 23.8% |
| 99285 emergency visit, high MDM | 70 | $164,273,212 | 14.3% | 9.2% to 19.3% |
| A0427 ambulance, ALS emergency | 68 | $156,804,531 | 10.4% | 2.5% to 18.2% |
| G0439 annual wellness visit, subsequent | 194 | $152,839,912 | 13.6% | 7.8% to 19.3% |
Source: CMS, Medicare FFS Supplemental Improper Payment Data, FY2025, Table L1.
Which codes had the highest overpayment rates?
Chronic care management led at 65.2%. CMS reviewed 68 claims for 99490 and found $2,662 overpaid out of $3,965 paid in the sample. The interval runs from 53.4% to 77.0%, so even the low end is above every other code in the top 20.
Outpatient therapy codes came next. Manual therapy (97140) had a 30.5% rate across 223 claims. Therapeutic exercises (97110) had 25.2%, therapeutic activities (97530) had 18.1%, and neuromuscular reeducation (97112) had 17.3% across 280 claims.
One lab code also stood out. Unlisted molecular pathology (81479) had a 26.0% rate over 367 claims. The sample overpaid $169,537 out of $640,836 paid, and CMS projected $114,983,372 in overpayments for the code.
In hospital care, subsequent visits at the high level (99233) had a 22.1% rate. The initial hospital visit at the high level (99223) had 13.1%. Emergency department visits at high decision-making (99285) were at 14.3%, and first-hour critical care (99291) was at 15.1% across 156 claims.
Which high-volume codes had low rates?
Some of the largest codes by dollars had rates near the Part B average or below it. The established office visit at 30 minutes (99214) had a 5.0% rate across 450 claims. The new patient visit at 45 minutes (99204) had 5.4% across 69 claims. Cataract removal without endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation (66984) had 5.6% across 211 claims.
All three sit below the 8.2% Part B overpayment rate. The 99214 interval, 3.3% to 6.6%, does not reach the Part B figure at all.
The 40-minute office visit (99215) ran at 14.8% across 226 claims. The jump from 5.0% at 99214 to 14.8% at 99215 sits within the same visit family.
The grouped lines moved less. Codes with fewer than 30 claims were grouped by CMS at a 6.6% rate across 5,242 claims. All other codes ran at 7.3% across 6,777 claims.
What do the ambulance codes show?
Four ambulance codes appear in the top 20. Basic life support (A0428) had a 12.8% rate across 131 claims. Ground mileage (A0425) had 12.4% across 204 claims. Basic life support emergency (A0429) had 12.2% across 68 claims, and advanced life support emergency (A0427) had 10.4% across 68 claims.
The intervals are wide. A0427 runs from 2.5% to 18.2%, and A0425 runs from 0.4% to 24.4%. With 68 claims in the sample for two of them, CMS cannot narrow the range much.
The annual wellness visit (G0439) had a 13.6% rate across 194 claims, with a $22,330 sample payment base. Practices that bill it can check the documentation requirements against the 7.8% to 19.3% interval CMS reports.
Table L1 lists the top 20 services by projected dollars. A code outside that list can still have a high rate, but CMS does not print it in this table.
Sources
Talk to us
Fifteen minutes about your practice and the systems you run.