Medicare Part B overpaid by an estimated $9,322,228,153 in fiscal year 2025, an overpayment rate of 8.2%, according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). The highest rate among the 20 largest codes was 65.2%, for chronic care management (99490).

CMS publishes the code-level detail in the supplemental tables of its CERT claims-review program. Table L1 ranks Part B services by projected overpaid dollars, so the list shows where the money went wrong and how often.

What does the FY2025 Part B error rate cover?

The FY2025 review covered Part B claims submitted from July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024. CMS sampled 11,920 Part B claims and reviewed 11,600 of them. Those claims held 24,983 service lines, and the reviewers paid out $19,047,116 in sample dollars.

Part B paid $114.1 billion in total that year. CMS projected $9.6 billion of it as improper, an improper payment rate of 8.4% with a 95% confidence interval of 7.6% to 9.3%. The overpayment rate in Table L1 is a little lower, 8.2%, because underpayments sit in the 8.4% figure but not in the overpayment figure.

CERT reviews a sample, so each rate carries a margin. A code with 68 reviewed claims has a much wider margin than a code with 450. The table below shows the interval next to every rate for that reason.

For comparison, CMS put the improper payment rate at 5.4% for Part A and 24.1% for durable medical equipment. Across all claim types the rate was 6.6% on $439.9 billion in payments, from 49,061 sampled claims.

Which Part B codes lost the most dollars?

The two largest dollar losses were hospital and office visits. CMS projected $490,503,977 in overpayments for subsequent hospital care at the high level (99233), and $459,838,842 for the established office visit at 30 minutes (99214). Together they account for $950,342,819 of projected overpayments.

The other large codes were therapy and care management services. The table lists the top ten from CMS Table L1, sorted by projected overpaid dollars.

CodeClaims reviewedProjected overpaid dollarsOverpayment rate95% interval
99233 subsequent hospital care, high334$490,503,97722.1%18.2% to 26.1%
99214 office visit, established, 30 min450$459,838,8425.0%3.3% to 6.6%
97110 therapeutic exercises214$286,653,22725.2%17.9% to 32.5%
99215 office visit, established, 40 min226$245,231,19914.8%11.6% to 18.1%
99490 chronic care management, first 20 min68$205,392,69965.2%53.4% to 77.0%
99223 initial hospital care, high282$182,122,22013.1%9.9% to 16.4%
97530 therapeutic activities245$179,101,99518.1%12.5% to 23.8%
99285 emergency visit, high MDM70$164,273,21214.3%9.2% to 19.3%
A0427 ambulance, ALS emergency68$156,804,53110.4%2.5% to 18.2%
G0439 annual wellness visit, subsequent194$152,839,91213.6%7.8% to 19.3%

Source: CMS, Medicare FFS Supplemental Improper Payment Data, FY2025, Table L1.

Which codes had the highest overpayment rates?

Chronic care management led at 65.2%. CMS reviewed 68 claims for 99490 and found $2,662 overpaid out of $3,965 paid in the sample. The interval runs from 53.4% to 77.0%, so even the low end is above every other code in the top 20.

Outpatient therapy codes came next. Manual therapy (97140) had a 30.5% rate across 223 claims. Therapeutic exercises (97110) had 25.2%, therapeutic activities (97530) had 18.1%, and neuromuscular reeducation (97112) had 17.3% across 280 claims.

One lab code also stood out. Unlisted molecular pathology (81479) had a 26.0% rate over 367 claims. The sample overpaid $169,537 out of $640,836 paid, and CMS projected $114,983,372 in overpayments for the code.

In hospital care, subsequent visits at the high level (99233) had a 22.1% rate. The initial hospital visit at the high level (99223) had 13.1%. Emergency department visits at high decision-making (99285) were at 14.3%, and first-hour critical care (99291) was at 15.1% across 156 claims.

Which high-volume codes had low rates?

Some of the largest codes by dollars had rates near the Part B average or below it. The established office visit at 30 minutes (99214) had a 5.0% rate across 450 claims. The new patient visit at 45 minutes (99204) had 5.4% across 69 claims. Cataract removal without endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation (66984) had 5.6% across 211 claims.

All three sit below the 8.2% Part B overpayment rate. The 99214 interval, 3.3% to 6.6%, does not reach the Part B figure at all.

The 40-minute office visit (99215) ran at 14.8% across 226 claims. The jump from 5.0% at 99214 to 14.8% at 99215 sits within the same visit family.

The grouped lines moved less. Codes with fewer than 30 claims were grouped by CMS at a 6.6% rate across 5,242 claims. All other codes ran at 7.3% across 6,777 claims.

What do the ambulance codes show?

Four ambulance codes appear in the top 20. Basic life support (A0428) had a 12.8% rate across 131 claims. Ground mileage (A0425) had 12.4% across 204 claims. Basic life support emergency (A0429) had 12.2% across 68 claims, and advanced life support emergency (A0427) had 10.4% across 68 claims.

The intervals are wide. A0427 runs from 2.5% to 18.2%, and A0425 runs from 0.4% to 24.4%. With 68 claims in the sample for two of them, CMS cannot narrow the range much.

The annual wellness visit (G0439) had a 13.6% rate across 194 claims, with a $22,330 sample payment base. Practices that bill it can check the documentation requirements against the 7.8% to 19.3% interval CMS reports.

Table L1 lists the top 20 services by projected dollars. A code outside that list can still have a high rate, but CMS does not print it in this table.

Sources

Talk to us

Fifteen minutes about your practice and the systems you run.

Book a demo