Medicare underpaid providers by about $1.0 billion in fiscal year 2025, or 0.2% of the $439.9 billion it paid on fee-for-service claims, according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Overpayments were $27.9 billion, or 6.3% of the same base.

CMS publishes both numbers from its CERT claims-review program. The underpayment tables in that file show which services Medicare paid too little for, and by how much.

How big are Medicare underpayments overall?

CERT works from a sample of claims, not the full file. CMS reviewed 37,651 claims in its 2025 sample. Across all claim types, the projected underpaid amount was $956,882,548, a rate of 0.2% with a 95% confidence interval of 0.2% to 0.3%. The overpaid amount in the same sample projected to $28,748,642,501, a rate of 6.5% before CMS adjusts for Part A to Part B rebilling.

After that adjustment, CMS reports a total improper payment rate of 6.6% and $28.8 billion. The table below shows how the underpaid share splits by claim type.

Claim typeTotal paidOverpayment rateUnderpayment rateUnderpaid dollars
Part A excluding hospital IPPS$197.9 billion6.6%0.1%$0.2 billion
Part A hospital IPPS$118.5 billion2.8%0.4%$0.5 billion
Part B$114.1 billion8.2%0.3%$0.3 billion
DMEPOS$9.4 billion24.1%0.1%$0.0 billion
All claim types$439.9 billion6.3%0.2%$1.0 billion

Source: CMS, 2025 Medicare Fee-for-Service Supplemental Improper Payment Data, Table A4 (adjusted for A/B rebilling). Dollars are rounded by CMS.

Where Part B underpayments concentrate

Part B covers physician office and outpatient services, so it matters most to independent practices. CMS projected $302,344,742 in underpaid Part B dollars across 11,600 claims and 24,983 lines reviewed. That is a 0.3% rate, with a confidence interval of 0.1% to 0.4%.

A few evaluation and management (E/M) visit codes account for most of the named dollars. A code for a low-level established office visit, 99213, led the list at $65,124,855. A new patient low-level visit, 99203, followed at $22,997,994.

CodeServiceClaims reviewedProjected underpaidUnderpayment rate
99213Office visit, established, low (20 min)188$65,124,8551.4%
99203Office visit, new, low (30 min)73$22,997,9943.4%
99231Subsequent hospital care, low (25 min)80$17,018,7727.3%
99308Subsequent nursing facility care, low72$16,865,8992.9%
J2777Injection, faricimab-svoa, 0.1 mg69$13,073,6941.3%
99233Subsequent hospital care, high (50 min)334$11,914,0900.5%

Source: CMS, 2025 Medicare Fee-for-Service Supplemental Improper Payment Data, Table M1. Each service needs at least 30 claims in the sample.

Smaller lines show higher rates. A 45-minute psychotherapy code, 90834, had $4,653,103 underpaid at 2.1% on 66 claims. The minimal established office visit code 99211 had a 4.6% rate but only $1,115,444 in dollars. A remote therapeutic monitoring add-on, 98981, had a 2.7% rate on 66 claims. Many of these rates have confidence intervals that cross zero, so CMS cannot rule out a true rate of 0.0%.

How underpayments compare with overpayments on the same codes

Part B overpayments projected to $9,322,228,153, an 8.2% rate with a confidence interval of 7.3% to 9.0%. The underpaid total of $302,344,742 is about 3.2% of that overpaid figure.

The mix by code differs too. The high-level subsequent hospital visit, 99233, carried $490,503,977 in overpayments at a 22.1% rate. Its underpayment was $11,914,090 at 0.5%. The established office visit at moderate level, 99214, showed $459,838,842 in overpayments at 5.0% and does not appear on the underpayment list.

CMS also reports upcoding errors by service type. Established office visits had $489,704,435 in upcoding errors at a 3.1% rate. Emergency room visits had a 9.2% rate, subsequent hospital visits 6.4% and nursing home visits 5.5%. For established office visits, the upcoding dollars are about 7.5 times the $65,124,855 underpaid on 99213.

What the error categories say about documentation

CMS sorts the $28.8 billion into five causes. Insufficient documentation is 53.0% of improper dollars, medical necessity 15.3%, no documentation 12.0%, incorrect coding 11.1% and other causes 8.5%. In dollars, incorrect coding is $3.2 billion, against $15.3 billion for insufficient documentation.

One-level E/M coding differences added up to $1,368,796,694, a 1.2% rate. The 99215 code, a high-level established visit, had a 14.8% improper rate and $245,231,199 in projected improper payments. The 99285 emergency visit had $164,273,212 at 14.3%.

CMS does not state a cause for the underpayments in Table M1. The tables give the dollar gap and the rate. They do not say whether the practice billed too low, the contractor priced the line wrong or the note supported a higher level.

What a billing team can check

The underpayment rates for single codes rest on small samples. The 99213 estimate comes from 188 claims, and its confidence interval runs from negative 0.4% to 3.1%. The 99203 estimate comes from 73 claims. Treat these rates as a pointer to where to look first.

The sample dollars show the same gap. In the Part B sample, reviewers found $118,797 underpaid and $1,815,598 overpaid on $19,047,116 paid. Across all claim types, $742,459 was underpaid and $24,353,395 overpaid on $281,736,696 paid.

Sources

Talk to us

Fifteen minutes about your practice and the systems you run.

Book a demo