CMS found upcoding in 1.4% of Medicare Part B payments in fiscal year 2025, which is $1,545,650,842 in projected improper payments. Upcoding means a claim billed a higher level of service than the record supports, and it is one cause inside the 8.4% Part B error rate.
The numbers come from the CMS 2025 Medicare Fee-for-Service Supplemental Improper Payment Data, published in November 2025. CMS reviewed 11,600 of 11,920 sampled Part B claims, from services billed between July 1, 2023 and June 30, 2024. The data covers Medicare fee-for-service only.
How much upcoding CMS found
CMS measured an 8.4% improper payment rate for Part B, or $9.6 billion on $114.1 billion in payments. The upcoding figure of $1,545,650,842 is 1.4% of Part B payments, with a 95% confidence interval of 1.2% to 1.5%. By our arithmetic, that is about 16.1% of all Part B improper dollars.
Across all of Medicare fee-for-service, CMS reports a 6.55% improper payment rate and a 93.45% accuracy rate for fiscal 2025. Part B, at 8.4%, runs above that program-wide rate.
Most Part B errors come from other causes, such as missing or thin records. Upcoding is the smaller part, but it sits in services that practices bill every day. The next table shows where it clusters.
Upcoding by type of visit
CMS groups Part B services by BETOS code and reports upcoding dollars for each group. The rate is the share of that group's payments that CMS found upcoded. The table lists the visit groups in CMS's order, which is by dollars.
| Service group | Upcoded dollars | Rate | 95% interval |
|---|---|---|---|
| Office visits, established | $489,704,435 | 3.1% | 2.4% to 3.8% |
| Hospital visit, subsequent | $327,624,133 | 6.4% | 5.3% to 7.6% |
| Office visits, new | $155,379,761 | 5.1% | 3.3% to 7.0% |
| Emergency room visit | $143,764,029 | 9.2% | 5.8% to 12.5% |
| Nursing home visit | $117,757,847 | 5.5% | 3.8% to 7.2% |
| Hospital visit, initial | $100,677,908 | 4.9% | 3.8% to 6.0% |
| Hospital visit, critical care | $72,389,339 | 7.6% | 3.7% to 11.5% |
| Home visit | $58,052,799 | 8.5% | 3.3% to 13.7% |
Source: CMS, 2025 Medicare Fee-for-Service Supplemental Improper Payment Data, Table K3. Base: Part B payments for each service group.
These eight visit groups add up to $1,465,350,251 of the $1,545,650,842 total. Established office visits carry the most dollars because they are the most common service. Their rate is 3.1%, one of the lowest on the list.
Which visits have the highest rates
Emergency room visits have the highest rate at 9.2%, or $143,764,029. Home visits follow at 8.5%, critical care at 7.6%, and subsequent hospital visits at 6.4%. For practices that bill in offices, the rate is 3.1% for established patients and 5.1% for new patients.
The intervals are wide for the smaller groups. Home visits run from 3.3% to 13.7%, and critical care from 3.7% to 11.5%. CMS drew those rates from fewer claims, so the point estimates move more between years.
Outside visits, CMS found almost no upcoding. Ophthalmology specialist services show 0.6%, psychiatry 0.3%, and skin procedures 0.2%. Chiropractic shows 0.2%, musculoskeletal imaging 0.3%, oncology 1.1%, and other drugs 0.0%. Every upcoding dollar in the 0.0% to 1.1% rows above is small next to the visit groups, and the three largest groups hold $972,707,...
One level can cost more than it looks
CMS also reports errors where the billed E/M code was one level off. The total is $1,368,796,694, or 1.2% of E/M payments, with an interval of 1.0% to 1.4%. In the K2 table, the largest share sits in a few codes.
- Subsequent hospital care, high level (99233): $258,923,334, or 11.7% of that code's payments.
- Established office visit, 30 minutes (99214): $238,758,920, or 2.6%.
- Established office visit, 40 minutes (99215): $144,385,324, or 8.7%.
- Emergency department visit, high decision making (99285): $130,096,685, or 11.3%.
The two office visit codes differ in rate but both matter. Code 99214 has a 2.6% rate on a large volume, and 99215 has an 8.7% rate on a smaller one. A practice that bills many 99214 visits can see more dollars at risk than one that bills a few 99215 visits at a higher rate.
CMS's E/M table also shows how much of each code's error is incorrect coding. For 99215, 72.5% of improper dollars come from incorrect coding. For 99214 the share is 62.5%, and for 99285 it is 87.5%. For all E/M codes together, incorrect coding is 50.0% of improper dollars, on a 10.1% overall E/M improper rate worth $3,265,045,695.
What a practice can check
CMS counts a one-level error in either direction as an error. A visit billed one level too low is also a mismatch, so a coding review that looks only for upcoding misses part of the picture.
A practice can pull a sample of paid visit claims, compare the level billed with the note, and record the result by code. If 4 of 40 sampled 99214 claims do not match the note, the practice has a 10.0% mismatch rate on that code. That number can be set beside the CMS rates in the table above.
The ER, home visit, and critical care rates are high but rest on small samples, so they suit practices that bill those services as a check rather than as a target. For office-based practices, the 3.1% and 5.1% rates are the closest comparison. Together, established and new office visits account for $645,084,196 of upcoded dollars.
Sources
Talk to us
Fifteen minutes about your practice and the systems you run.